The Six Main Vegetable Garden Mulches Compared
Garden compost (5–8cm): Best all-round choice. Suppresses weeds, retains moisture, feeds soil, improves structure. Apply in autumn or spring. Best choice for most gardens.
Wood chip (7–10cm on paths): Excellent for permanent paths between beds. Do not apply fresh wood chip to growing areas — microorganisms decomposing it temporarily lock up soil nitrogen. Well-aged (2+ year) wood chip is excellent as a bed mulch.
Straw (7–10cm): Traditional and effective. Excellent around strawberries (keeps fruits clean) and over overwintering crops. Can harbour slugs — check regularly.
Black polythene mulch film: Suppresses all weeds, warms soil (ideal for sweetcorn, courgettes, squash). Not biodegradable unless specifically labelled so.
Grass clippings (2–4cm): Free and effective nitrogen source. Apply thinly — thick layers mat together, excluding air and causing anaerobic decomposition. Avoid if lawn was recently treated with herbicides.
Newspaper (4–6 sheets): Effective temporary weed barrier. Wet before applying. Decomposes within a season. Best topped with compost or straw for a permanent path.